Learning from a loosing covered call

 

One of my goals for 2105 was to learn about options. And so I did. The best way to learn is to trade them, at least, that is how I look at it. Since June 2015 I trade options, more precise, I sell option premium.

Not all trades go as expected. In order to capitalise on my learning, I document some interesting trades on my blog.

In order to boost my dividend income of my positions, I sell covered calls on my stock. For now, I do this only on my play money.

Early October, I looked at my portfolio and noticed a stock that was available for a covered call. around that time, I thought it was a good idea to have always a covered call on all my shares. If things would not go my way, I would roll the position, just as I roll puts.

The learning trade

The graph below tells the story. On Oct 1st, I write a covered call with a strike of 23,5. The expiry date is November 20.

covered_call_lesson

In a few days time, the price goes up to 24, 5. At this time, the option is In The Money. If it stays here, I will need to sell the stock at a price of 23,5. When you write a contract, you know this…

The problem

Here is the problem: I did not really want to sell the stock at 23,5. This was too close to my initial average purchase price for that stock. Not that I am greedy – well maybe, it is my play portfolio.

Secondly, this stock is part of my play money portfolio, where I wanted to experiment with dividend stocks and options. Loosing the stock before I get to experiment with dividends and options during an extended period of time did not make sense too me.

IT could be called away. There is always the risk that someone exercises the option just before the dividend date to get the stock at a discount and get the dividend as a bonus. (There are some ways to calculate this, it has to do with the extrinsic value of the option compared to the dividend).

Why not roll?

I looked at rolling the position a few times, and discovered that it is not as easy as puts. This is most likely due to the option skew. In short: there is more premium in puts than in calls as stock tend to fall harder and faster than that they go up. As a result, I  needed to go out way too far in time to be able to roll the call to a higher level.

After about 3 weeks I made a tough call: I bought back the option with an important loss. You can see the loss in my 2015 evaluation.

The loss of about 71 euro is not nice, but if you consider that this is the price to pay to get good insights in covered call, than this is a bargain.

The lessons learned

Hence, I refreshed the rules for my covered calls, the hard way (often works best)

  • It needs to be a price that gives a good (approx 5pct) gain on the stock. This can either be the average buy price, or one of the entry points for that stock.
  • Make sure the expiration date is far enough away from an ex dividend date. Ideally, about 30 days or so.
  • Recently added due to the Belgian speculation tax: if the last buy of the stock is less than 6 months: make sure the strike is longer than the 6 month.

 

What are your rules for covered calls?

 

 

 

Advertisements

12 thoughts on “Learning from a loosing covered call

  1. My goal is to make a 10% return on a stock using a covered call. I usually pick a option with a time premium and a strike price that will give me a 10% total return if the stock is called away. If the stock isn’t called away then I will pick a lower strike price for my next option.

    Like

      1. I find that most stocks don’t go straight up, some of my most profitable trades have come from buying & selling the same stock as it moves up & down during a confirmed uptrend.

        Like

    1. Glad to hear it is helping you. These post have 2 goals: document my own learnings for later reuse, and share with others.
      There are some more coming up as it has been an interesting start of the year.

      AT

      Like

  2. Hey AT,
    you are a brave man, we will just stick to dividend growth stocks, index funds and real estate. Options seem too much gambling for our taste.
    Good luck though!

    Like

    1. Team CF,

      I think options get a bad rap. If you structure them right they can be rather conservative methods to enter positions.

      Here’s some articles explaining put options and how to use them.
      http://www.passive-income-pursuit.com/2014/08/the-best-of-both-worlds-put-options.html
      http://www.passive-income-pursuit.com/2012/09/option-strategy.html
      http://www.passive-income-pursuit.com/2012/06/put-options-explained.html

      I shockingly don’t have any articles on call options but my recent article on SA looks at V and some potential long dated calls that could be interesting.
      http://seekingalpha.com/article/3878056-calling-visa-cash

      If you do your due diligence and are comfortable owning the shares the options markets can actually give you higher income in the meantime via the premium or a lower cost basis. It’s something to look into.

      Like

      1. With the current speculation tax in Belgium (Pay 33pct tax on profit made when you sell within 6 months) These longer dated covered calls could be a good alternative. And you get to keep the dividend if it pays one…

        Like

  3. I don’t do much call writing because I feel that the positions I have were purchased for a reason and don’t want to lose the shares. Although I do want to build up some side capital, maybe $10k just to use for options and see how that goes.

    On both calls and puts I typically look for a 1% return per month that the option is open for durations of 6 months or less if the options expires and a good purchase/sale price if the option is executed. I’ve done okay on my options and have generated a decent return but it’s been awhile since I’ve explored the options world.

    Like

    1. Hey JC, that is what I am doing now… discovering options with some money I have set aside. I think the best way to learn is to tip my toes in the water.
      I try to only sell the calls at prices I am willing to sell the stock. I look at the delta of the option to see how much chance the market thinks there is to be executed. It is an indication, not a guarantee.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s